Saturday, March 24, 2012

Trading Is Hazardous to Your Wealth

An important aspect of investing in the stock market is how often you trade, which can be viewed on a continuum. At the high end of the continuum are day traders, who make several trades each day, rarely holding a position for more than a few minutes or hours. A bit further down are swing traders, who might hold a position for a few days or weeks. At the low end of the continuum are buy-and-monitor investors (which I think is a more appropriate label than "buy-and-hold"), who hold their positions for years or even decades as long as the fundamentals remain sound. Thus, when framed in terms of portfolio turnover, day/swing traders have very high turnover rates, whereas buy-and-monitor investors have very low turnover rates.

What is the effect of turnover on returns for individual investors? I recently came across a study that provides some relevant data. Barber and Odean (2000) looked at the relationship between common stock investment performance for individuals (not mutual fund managers or institutional investors) and the rate of portfolio turnover for a period from 1991-1996, in the midst of a bull market. During that time, the market returned an average of 17.9% per year. How did individual investors do?

Investors were divided into quintiles based on how often they traded. Interestingly, all groups had gross returns (before trading costs) that were very similar to each other and to the market. However, the groups differed in their net returns (after trading costs): The group that traded the least had a net return of 18.5%, which was almost equal to its gross return and slightly better than the market. The group that traded the most had a net return of 11.4%, despite having a gross return that was essentially identical to that of groups that traded less often, which means that a large chunk of their return was lost due to trading costs. Overall, the more that a group traded, the lower its net return. On average, individuals turned over about 75% of their portfolios annually.

These results and related findings show that frequent trading is detrimental to investing performance (in terms of net return). Barber and Odean (2000) suggested that one reason for this relationship is that some people become overconfident and overestimate the value of the news and information they learn about their stocks. This overconfidence compels them to act on their information, leading them to trade more often.

Based on such research, one of the principles of my investing strategy is to keep portfolio turnover at an absolute minimum. Last year I had some turnover because it was not until later in the year that I finally settled on the dividend-growth investing strategy that I now follow. Thus far this year I have had 0% turnover -- I have not sold a single stock (see my Transactions page). To minimize turnover, I adhere to a set of criteria associated with selling stocks that I plan to write about in the future. In addition, I completely refrain from day and swing trading, and I do not follow any sort of market-timing strategy. I think my approach is sensible and will ultimately result in investment performance that is in line with my goals.

Reference: Barber, B. M., & Odean, T. (2000). Trading is hazardous to your wealth: The common stock investment performance of individual investors. Journal of Finance, 55, 773-806. The article is available from Barber's website.

6 comments:

  1. Thanks for sharing this study Deedubs. I think it is findings like these that people want to use to defend why indexing is better than selecting individual stocks. For me I look at the results of such studies and look at the causes that I can keep from mimicking, in this case trading frequency. Avoiding some of these behaviors will keep us from making the same mistakes.

    I'm with you on keeping the turnover of a portfolio low. I have not sold any positions this year either. I did sell a few last year, but it was to take gains and helped me pay of my student loans.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Stoic Investor,

      I agree that if we understand how different factors such as trading frequency affect our returns, then we can structure our behavior in ways that minimize the negative effects. It sounds like you and I are taking very similar approaches with regard to portfolio turnover.

      Cheers,

      Deedubs

      Delete
  2. I completely concur Deedubs. Minimizing turnover (and therefore taxes and trading fees) is key to long-term wealth building, in my opinion.

    I am reminded of something that Chuck Carnevale said about how handling your portfolio is like handling soap: the more you handle it, the less you'll have.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Dividend Mantra,

      I think the soap analogy (which I've come across a few times now) provides a great way to think about the relationship between portfolio turnover and return. Minimizing portfolio turnover is indeed a key to building long-term wealth, as evidenced by some of the comments on SA from investors who have held stocks such as KO, PG, CL, MCD, etc., for decades and now receive thousands of dollars in dividends from each stock every year.

      Cheers,

      Deedubs

      Delete
  3. Nice post. I think some people are savvy enough to do well day trading. I know I'm not. Like you say, the majority of investors would be better off holding long term and therefore minimizing turnover. Another advantage is that after 1 year a holding become a long term position which lowers capital gains tax.

    I haven't sold anything so far in 2012. Last year I sold 3 positions for various reasons. I'm learning as I go.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Compounding Income,

      Thanks for your comment. I agree that most people should go with a long-term investing approach. Some people do succeed at day trading, but most do not and end up losing a lot of money. Like you, I know day trading is not for me. Fortunately, dividend-growth investing suits my goals, abilities, and risk tolerance quite nicely.

      Cheers,

      Deedubs

      Delete